A child can spend twenty minutes carefully drawing on a tablet or twenty minutes absentmindedly tracing the same shape on paper. The device alone doesn't tell you how involved they are.
Drawing apps are useful in some situations, less useful in others. We make a product that animates children's drawings, so we have a stake in this broader category. That doesn't make a tablet the best answer for every child.
What digital drawing does well
An undo button makes experimentation easy. A child can try a different color or move a line without starting again. A digital palette allows quick changes and unusual combinations. Saving and duplicating a picture also makes it possible to try several versions of the same idea.
These can be especially useful for an older child working on an illustration or a comic.
What paper still offers
Crayons, pencils, paint and paper behave physically. They have friction, texture and different levels of resistance. A child learns to control those materials while drawing. A stylus can provide some of that experience, but not all of it.
Paper also works without logins, notifications or a charged battery. There is something useful about an activity that needs nothing more than a pencil and a surface.
What to look for in an app
Choose a tool that lets children make their own drawings rather than only fill in templates. Check age suitability, advertising, in-app purchases, privacy and whether artwork can be exported. An app that makes it difficult to save work outside its own ecosystem may be frustrating later.
If the device offers easy access to unrelated apps, consider using parental controls and a time or place for drawing that suits your family.
How to combine the two
A child might sketch a character on paper, photograph it and use a digital app to color a different version. Or they might draw on a tablet and then print the picture to make a book. Neither activity makes the original drawing less important.
Animy sits after the drawing stage: it takes a photo of a drawing and creates a short styled animation. It isn't a drawing app that teaches children to use a pencil, nor does it replace the time spent making the original picture.
Offer both mediums when practical, and notice which one helps your child make the things they want to make.
Animy turns one drawing or photo into a short animation. See how it works, what it costs and how your pictures are handled.